Pros and Cons of Annuities: Honest Review for 2025
The complete truth about annuities—what they do well, and where they fall short
🌰 In a Nutshell
Annuities are powerful tools, but not perfect for everyone:
- Biggest Pros: Guaranteed lifetime income, principal protection, tax-deferred growth, no contribution limits
- Biggest Cons: Limited liquidity, surrender charges, potential fees, inflation risk, complexity
- Bottom Line: Annuities excel at providing safety and guaranteed income, but require long-term commitment and careful selection
- Who benefits most: Retirees seeking income security, people who've maxed out other retirement accounts, those afraid of market crashes
✓ Major Benefits of Annuities
Guaranteed Lifetime Income
You cannot outlive your money. Annuities provide income for life, even if you live to 110. This is the #1 reason people buy annuities—eliminating longevity risk.
Example
John deposits $300,000 and receives $1,800/month for life. If he lives 30 years, he'll receive $648,000 total—more than double his investment.
Principal Protection
Your money is safe from market crashes. Fixed and indexed annuities guarantee you won't lose your principal, even if the stock market crashes 40%.
Tax-Deferred Growth
No taxes on gains until withdrawal. Your money grows without annual tax drag, compounding faster than taxable accounts.
No Contribution Limits
Unlimited deposits. Unlike 401(k)s ($23,000 limit) or IRAs ($7,000 limit), you can put $500,000+ into an annuity.
Peace of Mind
Sleep better at night. No checking stock tickers. No worrying about timing the market. Your income is guaranteed.
Optional Long-Term Care Riders
Doubles or triples for LTC. Some annuities include riders that increase payouts 2X-3X if you need nursing home or assisted living care.
Probate Avoidance
Bypasses probate court. Annuities pass directly to beneficiaries, saving time and legal fees.
Replaces Missing Pensions
Creates your own pension. If your employer doesn't offer a pension, an annuity provides that same predictable monthly paycheck.
✗ Major Drawbacks of Annuities
Limited Liquidity
Your money is locked up. Most annuities have surrender charges lasting 5-10 years. Early withdrawals trigger penalties of 7-10% plus IRS penalties if under age 59½.
Example
You deposit $100,000 but need it back in Year 3. The insurance company charges an 8% surrender fee ($8,000), leaving you with $92,000 before taxes.
Fees (Variable Annuities)
Can be expensive. Variable annuities charge 2-3.5% annually in fees, which significantly reduces returns over time.
Inflation Risk
Fixed payments lose buying power. A $2,000/month payment today might feel like $1,200/month in 20 years due to inflation. (You can add COLA riders, but they reduce initial payments.)
Complexity
Confusing product. Annuities have dozens of riders, terms, and options. Many people don't fully understand what they're buying.
Opportunity Cost
May miss higher returns. The S&P 500 averages 10% annually over decades. Annuities typically earn 3-6%, meaning you sacrifice upside potential for safety.
Longevity Gamble
Die early, lose big. If you buy an immediate annuity and die 2 years later, the insurance company keeps your principal (unless you add costly riders).
Company Risk
Dependent on insurer strength. Your guarantees are only as good as the insurance company's financial stability. Choose A-rated or higher companies.
Commissions Built In
Agent incentives. Annuity salespeople earn 4-8% commissions, which can create conflicts of interest. Always get multiple quotes.
Not Sure if an Annuity Is Right for You?
Get an honest assessment of your situation with no pressure to buy.
📞 Talk to an Expert Get Free IllustrationWe'll help you understand both the benefits AND limitations before you decide
The Benefits: Explained in Detail
✓ Guaranteed Lifetime Income: The Primary Benefit
This is the single most powerful feature of annuities. You transfer longevity risk to the insurance company.
- What it means: No matter how long you live, your income continues
- Who it helps: People afraid of running out of money in retirement
- Real scenario: Your 401(k) might run dry at age 85, but your annuity keeps paying until 105
- Peace of mind: Covers essentials like housing, food, healthcare
✓ Principal Protection: Safety from Market Crashes
Fixed and indexed annuities guarantee your principal regardless of market performance.
- Fixed annuities: 100% safe with guaranteed interest rates
- Indexed annuities: 0% floor means you never earn negative returns
- 2008 crash comparison: S&P 500 dropped 38%, annuity holders earned 0% (protected)
- Best for: Risk-averse retirees who can't afford losses
⚠️ Exception
Variable annuities do NOT protect principal. You can lose money if your subaccounts perform poorly.
✓ Tax-Deferred Growth: Compound Faster
Earnings grow without annual taxes, letting your money compound more aggressively.
- Example: $100,000 earning 5% in a taxable account (25% tax rate) = $4.32/year per dollar
- Same $100,000 in annuity: $4.65/year per dollar (no annual taxes)
- Over 20 years: Tax-deferred account grows to $265,330 vs taxable $216,097
- Catch: You pay ordinary income tax on withdrawals (not capital gains rates)
✓ No Contribution Limits: Unlimited Deposits
Unlike retirement accounts with strict limits, annuities accept deposits of any size.
- 401(k) limit 2025: $23,000/year ($30,500 if age 50+)
- IRA limit 2025: $7,000/year ($8,000 if age 50+)
- Annuity limit: UNLIMITED (deposit $1 million if you want)
- Best for: High earners, business owners, people with windfalls (inheritance, home sale, pension buyout)
The Drawbacks: What You Need to Know
✗ Limited Liquidity: Your Money Is Locked
This is the #1 complaint about annuities. Early withdrawals are expensive.
- Surrender charges: 7-10% penalty for 5-10 years
- IRS penalty: Additional 10% if you're under age 59½
- Taxes: Ordinary income tax on gains
- Total cost example: Withdraw $50,000 early = $8,500 surrender charge + $5,000 IRS penalty + $10,000 taxes = $26,500 lost (53% gone!)
💡 Free Withdrawal Provision
Most annuities allow you to withdraw 10% per year penalty-free during the surrender period. This provides some emergency access.
✗ Fees: Variable Annuities Can Be Expensive
Not all annuities have high fees, but variable annuities can be costly.
- Fixed annuities: Typically $0 annual fees
- Indexed annuities: $0-$50/year administrative fees
- Variable annuities: 2.0-3.5% annually (very expensive)
| Fee Type | Fixed | Indexed | Variable |
|---|---|---|---|
| M&E (Mortality & Expense) | Included | Included | 1.0-1.5% |
| Administrative Fees | $0 | $0-$50/yr | $30-$50/yr |
| Investment Management | N/A | N/A | 0.5-1.0% |
| Optional Riders | 0.25-1.0% | 0.5-1.5% | 0.5-1.5% |
| TOTAL ANNUAL | 0.25-1.0% | 0.5-1.5% | 2.0-3.5% |
⚠️ Fee Impact
Over 20 years, a 2.5% annual fee reduces your ending balance by nearly 40% compared to a 0.5% fee product.
✗ Inflation Risk: Fixed Payments Lose Buying Power
If your annuity pays a fixed $2,000/month, inflation erodes that over time.
- Today: $2,000/month buys groceries, gas, utilities comfortably
- In 10 years (3% inflation): Same $2,000 feels like $1,488 in today's dollars
- In 20 years (3% inflation): Feels like $1,107 in today's dollars
- Solution: Add a COLA (Cost of Living Adjustment) rider, but it reduces initial payments by 20-30%
✗ Complexity: Hard to Understand
Annuities are among the most complex financial products, with confusing terminology.
- Riders: GLWB, GMAB, GMIB, GMWB—alphabet soup of options
- Crediting methods: Annual point-to-point, monthly averaging, participation rates, cap rates
- Surrender schedules: Vary by company and product
- Tax treatment: LIFO (last in, first out) on withdrawals
💡 Work with a Fiduciary
A fiduciary advisor is legally required to act in YOUR best interest, not their commission. Always ask: "Are you a fiduciary?"
✗ Opportunity Cost: Missing Market Upside
By choosing safety, you sacrifice potential higher returns from stocks.
- S&P 500 historical average: ~10% annually over long periods
- Fixed annuity typical return: 3-5% annually
- Indexed annuity typical return: 4-7% annually
- Gap over 30 years: $100k at 10% = $1.74M vs $100k at 5% = $432k
💡 Balance is Key
Smart retirees often allocate 30-50% to annuities for guaranteed income, and keep 50-70% in stocks/bonds for growth potential.
Who Benefits Most from Annuities?
Retirees Without Pensions
If you don't have a pension, an annuity creates that guaranteed monthly paycheck
Risk-Averse Individuals
Can't sleep when the market crashes? Annuities eliminate that stress
Maxed-Out Savers
Already maxing 401(k) and IRA? Annuities offer unlimited contributions
Long Lifespan Families
If your parents lived to 95+, an annuity protects against outliving savings
Windfall Recipients
Inherited money? Sold a business? Convert lump sums into lifetime income
LTC Concerns
LTC annuity riders provide 2X-3X benefits for nursing home care
Who Should Avoid Annuities?
Need Liquidity
If you might need your money within 10 years, annuities aren't a good fit
Want Maximum Growth
Young investors (under 50) seeking aggressive growth should stick with stocks
Poor Health
If you have serious health issues limiting lifespan, annuities don't make sense
Want to Leave Large Legacy
Annuities prioritize your income over leaving inheritance (though options exist)
Don't Understand Product
Never buy something you don't fully understand—take time to learn
Already Have Guaranteed Income
If Social Security + pension cover all expenses, you may not need more
🎯 The Verdict: Are Annuities Worth It?
It depends on your situation.
Annuities are excellent for people who prioritize safety, guaranteed income, and peace of mind over maximum growth potential.
Annuities are poor choices for people who need liquidity, want aggressive growth, or don't fully understand the product.
💡 Best Practice
Most financial planners recommend allocating 30-50% of retirement savings to annuities for guaranteed income, keeping the rest in growth-oriented investments. This balances safety with growth potential.
Get a Personalized Annuity Assessment
We'll review YOUR situation and help you understand if an annuity makes sense—no sales pressure.
📞 Call for Free Consultation Request Free QuoteHonest guidance on pros, cons, and alternatives to annuities
Continue Learning About Annuities
Protect Your Life First, So We Can Protect Your Legacy
At MaxFunded IUL, we provide honest, transparent guidance on annuities—showing you both benefits and limitations so you can make informed decisions.
Schedule Free Consultation