Should I choose an annuity or 401(k) for retirement?

Most people should max out their 401(k) first to get the employer match (free money), then consider adding an annuity for guaranteed lifetime income. The 401(k) provides growth potential while the annuity provides safety and income guarantees. Many retirees use both.

Can I roll my 401(k) into an annuity?

Yes, you can roll a 401(k) into an annuity tax-free when you retire or leave your employer. This is common for people who want to convert their 401(k) balance into guaranteed lifetime income. The rollover maintains the tax-deferred status.

Which has better returns: annuity or 401(k)?

A 401(k) invested in stocks typically has higher long-term returns (7-10% average) but with volatility. Annuities offer more modest returns (3-6%) but with safety and guaranteed income. The 401(k) is better for growth, annuities better for safety.

Do annuities have contribution limits like 401(k)s?

No, annuities have unlimited contribution limits. You can deposit $500,000 or more if you want. In contrast, 401(k)s have annual limits of $23,000 (or $30,500 if age 50+) as of 2025. This makes annuities attractive for high earners.

What are the main differences between an annuity and 401(k)?

Key differences: 401(k)s require an employer and have contribution limits but offer employer match. Annuities have no contribution limits, no employer requirement, and provide guaranteed lifetime income. 401(k)s offer higher growth potential; annuities offer safety and guarantees.

Annuity vs 401k - MaxfundedIUL

🌰 In a Nutshell

401(k) = Growth Tool: Higher returns (7-10% average), employer match, but market risk and no guaranteed income
Annuity = Safety Tool: Guaranteed lifetime income, principal protection, unlimited contributions, but lower returns (3-6%)
Best Strategy: Max out 401(k) first (get the employer match!), then add annuity for guaranteed income
At Retirement: Many people roll part of their 401(k) into an annuity to create guaranteed lifetime income
Bottom Line: They serve different purposes—use both for a complete retirement plan

Quick Overview: Annuity vs 401(k)

💰 Annuity

"The Safety & Income Tool"

Guaranteed lifetime income you cannot outlive
Principal protected from market crashes
Unlimited contributions (no $23k limit)
No employer required
Tax-deferred growth
Lower returns (3-6% typical)
Limited liquidity (surrender charges 5-10 years)

📊 401(k)

"The Growth & Match Tool"

Higher growth potential (7-10% average)
Employer match (free money!)
Tax-deferred growth
Contribution limit: $23,000/yr ($30,500 if 50+)
Requires employer sponsorship
Market risk (can lose money)
No guaranteed income (you manage withdrawals)

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Feature	401(k)	Annuity
Employer Required?	✓ Yes (must be offered by employer)	✓ No (buy directly from insurance company)
Contribution Limits	$23,000/yr ($30,500 if age 50+)	UNLIMITED (Can deposit $500,000+)
Employer Match	Yes (typically 3-6% of salary) Free money!	No
Tax Treatment	Pre-tax contributions Tax-deferred growth Taxed at withdrawal	After-tax contributions Tax-deferred growth Only gains taxed
Expected Returns	7-10% average (based on stock market history)	3-6% average (safer, more predictable)
Market Risk	Yes—can lose money in downturns	No—fixed & indexed protect principal
Guaranteed Income	No—you manage withdrawals Risk of running out	Yes—lifetime income guaranteed Cannot outlive
Liquidity	Good (can withdraw anytime) But 10% penalty before 59½	Limited (surrender charges 5-10 yrs) Same 10% penalty before 59½
Fees	0.5-1.5% annually (fund management fees)	Fixed/Indexed: $0-$50/yr Variable: 2-3.5%/yr
Investment Control	Full control (choose your investments)	Limited/None (insurance company manages)
Required Withdrawals	RMDs at age 73	RMDs at age 73 (if qualified annuity)
Best For	• Accumulation years • Growth focus • Ages 25-60	• Pre-retirement/retirement • Income focus • Ages 50-75

Should You Use a 401(k), Annuity, or Both?

Get personalized guidance on the right retirement strategy for YOUR situation.

📞 Talk to an Expert Get Free Annuity Quote

(800) 525-8495

We'll help you coordinate your 401(k) and annuity strategy

Real Example: Meet David, Age 55

David's Situation

David earns $100,000/year and has been saving for retirement. He has $500,000 in his 401(k) and wants to maximize his retirement income.

Option 1: Keep Everything in 401(k)

Current Balance: $500,000
Continues Contributing: $23,000/year + $8,000 employer match
At Age 65 (7% growth): $1,230,000
Retirement Income Strategy: 4% withdrawal rule = $49,200/year
Risk: Market crash could reduce balance; might outlive savings

Option 2: Hybrid Strategy (BEST)

Keep $300k in 401(k) for growth (continues contributions)
Roll $200k to annuity for guaranteed income
At Age 65:
• 401(k) grows to ~$820,000
• Annuity provides $1,200/month guaranteed (for life)
Total Retirement Income: $1,200/mo guaranteed + 401(k) withdrawals + Social Security
Benefit: Guaranteed income covers basics; 401(k) provides extras and legacy

💡 Why the Hybrid Strategy Wins

David gets the best of both worlds: guaranteed income from the annuity (can't outlive it) PLUS growth potential from the 401(k) (for inflation protection and legacy). His essential expenses are covered by the annuity, so he can be more aggressive with the 401(k).

When to Choose 401(k) vs Annuity

📊

Choose 401(k) If...

You're under age 50 and in accumulation phase
Your employer offers a match (never leave free money!)
You want maximum growth potential
You're comfortable with market risk
You want investment control
You're 10+ years from retirement

💰

Add Annuity If...

You're within 10 years of retirement
You've maxed out your 401(k) and want more tax deferral
You want guaranteed income you cannot outlive
You're afraid of market crashes
You don't have a pension
You want to ladder income (some guaranteed, some variable)

🏆 The Optimal Strategy: Use BOTH

Most financial experts recommend a hybrid approach that combines the strengths of both:

The 3-Phase Retirement Strategy

Phase 1: Ages 25-50 (Accumulation)

• Focus 100% on 401(k)
• Max out employer match
• Aggressive stock allocation (80-90%)
• Don't think about annuities yet

Phase 2: Ages 50-65 (Pre-Retirement)

• Continue maxing 401(k) for match
• If you have extra funds, add deferred annuity
• Start shifting 401(k) to more conservative investments
• Let deferred annuity grow tax-deferred

Phase 3: Age 65+ (Retirement)

• Roll 30-50% of 401(k) into immediate annuity for guaranteed income
• Keep 50-70% in 401(k) for growth and flexibility
• Essential expenses covered by annuity + Social Security
• Use 401(k) for discretionary spending and emergencies

💡 Why This Works

You capture the employer match and growth potential in your working years (401k), then convert part of it to guaranteed income in retirement (annuity). This creates a "retirement paycheck" that covers basics while maintaining flexibility and growth potential.

Can You Roll Your 401(k) Into an Annuity?

Yes! This is one of the most common retirement strategies.

💡 How 401(k) to Annuity Rollover Works

You retire or leave your employer (or reach age 59½)
Contact the annuity insurance company and request a direct rollover
The insurance company coordinates with your 401(k) provider
Money transfers directly (never touches your hands = no taxes)
Your 401(k) balance becomes a qualified annuity (same tax treatment)
You choose when to start income (immediately or deferred)

⚠️ Important: Direct Rollover Only

Always do a direct rollover (also called trustee-to-trustee transfer). If you take the money yourself, the IRS withholds 20% for taxes and you have only 60 days to deposit it into the annuity. Direct rollovers avoid this hassle entirely.

Example: Rolling $400k from 401(k) to Annuity

Scenario: Linda, age 65, retires with $600,000 in her 401(k).

Decision: Roll $400,000 to immediate annuity; keep $200,000 in IRA
Annuity Payment: $2,600/month for life (guaranteed)
IRA: Grows and provides emergency access
Total Income: $2,600 annuity + Social Security $2,200 = $4,800/month guaranteed
Result: All essential expenses covered; IRA for travel, gifts, unexpected costs

Contribution Limits: 401(k) vs Annuity

Account Type	2025 Annual Limit	Age 50+ Catch-Up	Total Limit (Age 50+)
401(k)	$23,000	+$7,500	$30,500
Annuity	UNLIMITED	UNLIMITED	UNLIMITED

💡 Why Unlimited Contributions Matter

If you're a high earner, business owner, or receive a windfall (inheritance, business sale, home sale), annuities let you shelter unlimited amounts with tax-deferred growth. This is especially valuable after maxing out your 401(k) and IRA.

High Earner Example

Michael, age 52, earns $300,000/year and just sold his business for $2 million.

Maxes 401(k): $30,500
Maxes IRA: $8,000
Still has $1,961,500 to invest!
Solution: Deposits $1 million into deferred indexed annuity
Benefit: Tax-deferred growth for 13 years until retirement at 65
At age 65: $1M grows to ~$2.1M (at 6% average), then converts to $13,000/month lifetime income

🎯 The Verdict: Which Should You Choose?

Don't choose—use BOTH!

✓ Always max your 401(k) first to get the employer match (free money)
✓ If you have extra savings, add a deferred annuity for tax-deferred growth
✓ At retirement, roll 30-50% of your 401(k) into an immediate annuity for guaranteed income
✓ Keep the rest in your 401(k)/IRA for growth, flexibility, and legacy

This hybrid strategy gives you guaranteed income, growth potential, and peace of mind.

Ready to Build Your Hybrid Retirement Strategy?

Get expert guidance on combining your 401(k) and annuities for maximum retirement income.

📞 Schedule Free Consultation Get Annuity Quote

(800) 525-8495

We'll show you how to coordinate your 401(k) and annuity for optimal results

Continue Learning

💰

Annuity vs IRA

Compare annuities to IRA accounts

Read Comparison →

📊

Types of Annuities

Fixed, indexed, and variable options

Explore Types →

⚖️

Pros and Cons

Honest review of annuities

Read Review →

📚

What Is an Annuity?

Start with the basics

Learn More →

Protect Your Life First, So We Can Protect Your Legacy

At MaxFunded IUL, we help you coordinate your 401(k) and annuity strategy for maximum retirement security.

Get Your Retirement Plan

Annuity vs 401(k): Which Is Better for Retirement in 2025?